An overview of how UX auditing can save you money and increase sales. Brought to you by WANDR, ranked the leader in digital design and product strategy by Clutch. We specialize in UX audits, please ask about our services.
A UX audit is a structured review of a website, app, or software product that finds where users struggle, explains why, and ranks the fixes by business impact. UX auditing combines expert review against usability heuristics, analytics, and feedback from real users.
Without a quality UX, users or customers are likely to seek solutions from the competition. UX auditing helps uncover issues that may hurt the overall presentation of your dashboard, website, or application.
An extensive audit may find some of the most frequent UX mistakes that result in poor UX.
What is poor UX? If you look at examples of bad UX websites, you will see many avoidable errors.
Discovering these mistakes allows designers to enhance the UX to boost sales, customer satisfaction, and other key metrics.
So what is a UX audit? What is a good user experience? What is poor UX? For answers to these questions, use the following UX auditing guide. At WANDR, we offer top of the line UX audit services for your ux auditing needs.
What Is a UX Audit?
A UX audit looks at five inputs together:
- User needs
- Business objectives
- Conversion metrics
- Customer feedback
- Sales data
Nielsen Norman Group's 10 usability heuristics for user interface design are a useful checklist for spotting these issues.
The audit includes a thorough look at every detail of your software. Auditors want to look at the motivations that went into the design, including user needs and business objectives. However, UX auditing also provides a detailed examination of current metrics and data.
Auditors attempt to determine what is working and what is not. They also help determine if you need to collect different metrics.
UX auditing does not automatically correct any mistakes. The auditors simply provide you with recommendations based on the research that they complete.
Basically, the audit helps determine if your interface delivers a poor UX.
What is poor UX? To understand the most common UX issues, you first need to know what goes into a good UX.
Who Needs a UX Audit and When Should You Run One?
A UX audit flags the parts of a product that block users from completing their tasks. It solves a common problem: not knowing what is keeping a product from growing. It does that in three ways:
- It shows which specific parts need fixing, without a complete overhaul of the product.
- It removes the guesswork from deciding where to focus.
- It sets a baseline for the current experience, so you can measure the improvements that follow.
Who needs one
Anyone responsible for the performance of a digital product, including CMOs, Heads of Product and CEOs, can get value from a UX audit. Audits are especially useful for companies dealing with low customer retention, high churn, high drop-off rates or a rising number of support tickets. Designers and strategists use them too, to turn a general sense that the experience is poor into a concrete, prioritized list of issues.
When to run one
Run a UX audit before any change that will alter the experience of your product. It should be the first step in a redesign or major enhancement. For product companies, running one at least once a year catches issues that build up over several development cycles and helps the team start the year focused on what matters most to customers.
A UX audit is also the right move when a product works technically but underperforms: the site loads fast and the features work, yet engagement stays low, users do not convert and support keeps hearing the same complaints. Analytics can show where users drop off. An audit connects those symptoms, such as high bounce rates or abandoned flows, to root causes like poor content hierarchy, inconsistent UI patterns or confusing multi-step processes.
At what product stage
Audits are not a one-time event. Early in development, auditing competing products can expose gaps in the market and give your team a blueprint that reduces costly design missteps. As the design evolves, audits of prototypes and wireframes confirm that usability guidelines are met and catch problems before release. After launch, regular audits keep the experience aligned with how users actually behave.
How to Do a UX Audit in 6 Steps
- Set goals and scope. Pick the business metric you want to move (sign-ups, activation, checkout completion) and the three to five flows that drive it.
- Review the data. Use analytics to find the steps where most users drop off, and session recordings to see what they do there.
- Run a heuristic evaluation. Walk each flow against Nielsen Norman Group's 10 usability heuristics. NN/g recommends three to five evaluators working independently, because one reviewer misses many issues.
- Test with real users. Watch people try the same tasks. Jakob Nielsen's research found that about five users per round uncover roughly 85% of usability problems.
- Rate and prioritize. Score each issue on NN/g's 0 to 4 severity scale (0 = not a problem, 4 = usability catastrophe), then weigh it by how many users hit it and what it costs the business.
- Report and plan. Turn findings into annotated screens, a recommended fix for each issue, and a roadmap your team can schedule.
A heuristic review on its own is fast and cheap, but it tells you what an expert thinks, not what your users do. The strongest UX audits combine both.
What Is a Good User Experience?
UX auditing allows you to improve the quality of your software. However, implementing best practices for UX design helps you avoid some of the most frequent UX mistakes.
If you want to know “what is a good user experience?”, follow the best practices for UX design, which starts with UX research.
UX designers or a dedicated research team should analyze the needs of users and the objectives of the business to devise an effective framework for the project.
So what is a good user experience? A quality UX provides users with the information or features they need. It should also contain the following elements:
- Simple interface and layout
- Visually appealing design
- Access to relevant information
UX auditing helps explore these details. For example, an auditor may use usability testing to examine whether your product offers a simple navigational structure.
What Are the Most Frequent UX Mistakes?
Understanding the most frequent UX mistakes and exploring examples of bad UX websites also helps designers create a better user experience.
So what is poor UX? A poor UX tends to include at least one of the following most frequent UX mistakes:
- Prioritizing business objectives
- Using too many innovative features
- Not using a responsive design
- Cluttering the page with elements
- Not providing simple navigation
These issues can cost you severely. The most frequent UX mistakes limit customer satisfaction. Think of software that you have used and disliked. If you become frustrated, you may stop using the software.
UX auditing helps detect some of these mistakes. However, these are mistakes that you can learn to avoid in the first place.
Prioritizing Business Objectives Over Customer Needs
During UX auditing, auditors look at the needs of customers and the business. However, prioritizing the objectives of the business over the customer tends to result in an inferior UX.
When you design for yourself, you overlook the details that provide a quality UX. Avoid adding features simply because you want them. Focus on the needs of the customers first and the interests of your SaaS business second.
Unfortunately, UX designers tend to develop a strong attachment to their creative projects. They may try to implement certain elements that they feel strongly about even when they offer no benefit to the end user. This tends to lead to the second-most frequent mistake.
Using Innovative Elements That Reduce Clarity
Innovation is an important part of UX design but it can become a burden. If the innovation makes the software more difficult to navigate or use, it fails to add any real value to the project.
Basically, avoid adding clever elements at the risk of confusing your users. The goal of the UX design is to guide users. If the features on the page become too difficult to use or navigate, your customers will not enjoy the experience.
Not Using a Responsive Design for Mobile Devices
A quality UX design should work on the devices that customers tend to use. If your customers want the flexibility of accessing your software on mobile devices, your software needs to load properly on smaller screens.
One of the simplest solutions for creating an interface that works on any device is to use a responsive design. The elements and layouts adjust based on the size of the screen.
Adding Too Many Elements on the Page
Another frequent mistake is the use of too many elements. Cluttering the page with advertisements or supplementary information takes away from the point of the page or dashboard.
Each page, menu, or dashboard screen should have one clear focus. If users want additional information, they can navigate to a different page or screen.
Not Providing a Simple Navigational Structure
Most examples of bad UX websites fail to give users a clean, simple interface. This is one of the costliest mistakes.
Keep things simple. Almost everything should be reachable within one or two clicks from the first page or screen that loads. If users need to drill down through multiple sub-menus, they may never find the information that they need, which takes away from their overall user experience.
With UX auditing, you can determine if your software contains any of these costly mistakes or the dozens of other mistakes that SaaS businesses often make when designing their interfaces.
What a UX Audit Report Should Include
The audit ends with a report that is easy to digest. It should give a clear picture of the current experience and an action plan your team can schedule. A useful report includes:
- A short summary of each activity, such as the stakeholder kickoff, journey mapping, heuristic evaluation and user interviews, with the most important insight from each.
- Every finding with the screen, the problem, the evidence and the recommended fix.
- Recommendations ranked on an impact and effort scale, so you can decide what to do first based on your team's capacity.
- The metrics each fix should move, so you can validate the changes after they ship.
How long does a UX audit take?
It depends on the size and complexity of the product. Audits typically range from about 2 weeks for a small startup product to several months for a large enterprise platform.
UX audit vs. usability test
A usability test watches real users try tasks in a product to find friction points. A UX audit is broader. It reviews analytics, content structure, design consistency and accessibility alongside usability principles, and it often includes usability testing as one of its inputs.
Types of UX Audits
"UX audit" covers several kinds of review. Most projects combine two or three.
- Heuristic evaluation: experts check the interface against established usability principles.
- Usability audit: real users attempt key tasks while you measure success, errors, and time.
- Analytics and funnel audit: behavior data shows where users drop off and which steps lose the most traffic.
- Accessibility audit: a check against WCAG 2.2 AA for contrast, keyboard use, labels, and screen readers.
- UX writing audit: a review of microcopy, such as button labels, error messages, empty states, and onboarding text, for clarity, consistency, and tone.
- UI and design system audit: an inventory of components and styles that finds duplicates, gaps, and inconsistencies.
UX Audit Example: What a Finding Looks Like
A useful finding names the screen, the problem, the evidence, and the fix. On a sign-up page, a typical audit might flag three issues: no value proposition above the fold, no password rules shown until after an error, and an unclear hierarchy between the primary and secondary buttons. Each would get a severity score, a recommended fix, and the metric it should move, in this case sign-up completion.
In a real engagement for Buildbox, a no-code game platform, WANDR's UX audit combined heuristic evaluation, funnel analytics, heatmaps, and session replays to find where new users quit. After onboarding was rebuilt, 41% more users reached their first success milestone.
Auditing a software product? Our SaaS UX audit checklist covers onboarding, activation, roles, and trial-to-paid flows. When you want an outside team, see our UX audit services.
The Dos and Don’ts of a UX Audit
Getting the most out of your UX audits depends on how you approach your auditing priorities. Unfortunately, companies can make a few missteps when effectively assessing user experience and making the necessary modifications to their designs. That's why it's important to be aware of common mistakes in UX audits and know a few dos and don'ts when tackling your UX audits.
Do Understand Your Goals
Before you begin an audit, you should have a clear understanding of what exactly you are trying to achieve - whether that's enhancing user experience, boosting engagement, or trimming down customer support inquiries. Zeroing in on your goals will simplify data collection and streamline its analysis for optimal outcomes.
Don't Overlook User Research
User research is an essential part of any UX audit. By engaging with users and obtaining valuable insights into their perspectives, you can uncover opportunities for innovation and enhancement of your products. Prioritizing comprehensive user research is the key to crafting a unique brand experience, helping you ensure that every detail of the journey is optimized to perfection.
Do Prioritize Actionable Insights
When conducting a UX audit, some companies can become overwhelmed by the sheer amount of data to review. But the key lies in discovering "actionable" insights, those golden nuggets of information that help open the doors to actual implementation, further investigations, or better testing guidelines. This is where the expertise of a consultant can come in handy, allowing you to ascertain which areas to prioritize and how to efficiently convert feedback into tangible results.
Don't Forget to Validate Changes
Before any UX audit is complete, it's crucial to validate the changes and ensure user experience goals are met. This should be done by conducting A/B testing, exploring analytics data, or running through usability tests. Doing so will confirm that the entire process - from beginning to end - was a success.
Tools and Metrics Used in UX Audits
UX audits are typically conducted using a variety of tools that help to discover hidden insights and measure user performance. Heat maps, click maps and scroll maps are used to track where users spend the most time on your site, while surveys and tree tests provide valuable feedback on what works and what needs improvement. Other tools include A/B testing, analytics tracking, and usability tests to help make sure user experiences are on-point.
In addition to using the right tools for the job, UX audits are focused on uncovering and tracking useful metrics that help businesses better understand where and how improvements to their design can be most impactful. Valuable metrics to track include task completion rates, time on task, clicks per session, conversion rate optimization (CRO), and accessibility metrics. Usability metrics such as error rate show how well people use the product, while engagement metrics such as bounce rate and session duration point to patterns worth a closer look. All of these work together to provide the bigger picture of how your UX is being perceived and interacted with.
How UX Audits Impact Sales
The brutal fact is that the way that your potential customers engage with your site determines your sales and your market reputation. A site or application that is tricky to use, difficult to navigate, and aesthetically unappealing will lose sales and will cost you the bottom line.
If you’re wondering why your potential customers are not converting and not engaging with your online presence, you need a UX audit. Once you understand where your customers are falling off, you can make positive changes.
The most damaging UX issues are rarely the ones that break a product. They are the ones that slowly erode trust. When the experience does not match what users expect, many will not complain. They will just leave. Poor UX raises support costs, lowers retention and turns acquisition spend into lost opportunities, while the team keeps building on a weak foundation.
Last Thoughts on UX Auditing
In the end, UX auditing is a useful method for improving your services. If you are not happy with your current sales figures, conversion rates, or other metrics, use an audit for an impartial review of your UX.
Want a second set of eyes? UX audits from our UX agency combine heuristic evaluation, funnel analytics, heatmaps, and session replays.
Here is a quick recap of why you need an audit.
What is a UX audit? UX auditing uncovers issues with the design of your software. The goal is to create a better user experience.
What is a good user experience? A good UX offers a simple, clear layout and relevant features or information. It should meet the needs of your users.
What is poor UX? A poor UX fails to meet the needs of users. There are many examples of bad UX websites. They typically load poorly on mobile devices or take too long to load. They may also have cluttered layouts or complicated menus.
Remember to avoid the most frequent UX mistakes. Look at examples of bad UX websites to see what other SaaS businesses did wrong and avoid repeating their errors.
So what is a UX audit and why do you need one? An audit simply helps you find room for improvement. Consider using UX auditing to fine-tune your software.
Need a team to do this?
If your team does not have the time or research capacity to audit in-house, our UX audit services cover websites, SaaS and enterprise products, and end with a prioritized roadmap your team can act on. Book a UX audit call to talk through what you want reviewed.
Related reading: Enhance Website Usability: Try Our UX Audit.
What Did You Learn About UX Auditing?
Let us know in the comments below.
Talk to us on LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook, or Twitter.


